TheMainSail
JohnGoode_18-10-07 AD
  
 Home » News > SeamanshipSaturday 11 October 2008 | Personalise | Help  
Free weekly newsletter!
Join TheMainSail now
Members can use the forum and gallery, receive a weekly newsletter and are eligible to win great prizes!
why join?  

Essential reading from our sponsors
Kipper Sailing
RYA approved practical yachting and theory courses

Specialist retailers, services and events
More Online Chandlers!
Are you a retailer?
Mustang Sailing

Forum Hot Threads
11416 Total Messages
Manson Supreme Anchor
by Cathy Brown
» Loads More Threads

Quick links

 SEAMANSHIP 08 / 05 / 06
 

Oops! The £250,000 crunch

Beneteau Oceanis 473
Claimed by Anvil Point, a Beneteau Oceanis 473 like the one that sank last weekend.
Picture: www.beneteauusa.com

How much does it cost for an RYA Competent Crew course? Not £250,000, that's for sure. Which makes it an awfully expensive way of teaching your girlfriend to sail if all you have is a Beneteau Oceanis 473 and the rocks at Anvil Point down in Swanage.

Only two ticks

Leave her at the wheel and pop below deck to check your satnav, which also costs more than an RYA course, and you're asking for trouble. Especially if - bless her little cotton socks - said girlfriend has only ever sailed a 15-foot dinghy before.

I turned round and...

But it's strange what people do, eh? Because that was the course Paul Compton chose over the May Day weekend when he went cruising down towards Lulworth Cove in Dorset. And not very surprisingly his brand-new, out-of-the-box Beneteau went aground on Anvil Point and sank - taking the keys to his late-model Porsche complete with vanity-reg number including "007" with it, pitching him and his girl friend into the briny.

Not a happy bunny when he got back to Lymington.

What price experience?

But like always when folks set out to sea without taking the odd precaution, for a merry little coastal cruise, this one had all the makings of a serious bad hair day.

Item one: if you're going out single-handed, what's your back-up?

Item two: if you have back-up, like another member of crew, how good are they?

Rescued by professionals

Thanks to the dear old RNLI, these two folks have lived to tell the tale. One was plucked off the rocks by a RIB braving it in through white water with plenty sharp objects to make a largeish hole, the other was picked up by Coast Guard chopper hovering where cliff updrafts could write you off at any second.

But what if exactly the same thing happened, with exactly the same people off the coast of, say, Mauritania? You know, one of those places where there is no RNLI? Bye, bye yacht - but what about the crew? Who in their right mind wants to be a statistic?


Paul Compton's 47-foot <i>Wellworthy</i>
Who's watching the helm? Paul Compton's 47-foot Wellworthy pays the price for lack of experience at the wheel.
Picture: www.itv.com

The cost of inattention

When you're dead, you're dead, right? So where's the sense in buying yourself a nice big yacht if somebody has to die for it? And how the hell do you live with your conscience when they do?

Thank God the RNLI are as hot as they are. Thank God that other mariners rally round as urgently as they do. Among others, Messrs Compton and Gutteridge owe their survival to the crew of Condor Vitesse, a cross-Channel catamaran, that heard their call and diverted to the area.

Would you divert, knowing that somebody had put to sea without verifying that they were properly RYA competent? Well yes, of course you would, we boating types recognise our responsibility to everyone else, capable or not.

Except that why should the RNLI be expected to scramble when their "customers" are needlessly taking risks that endanger their own lives?

The real price tag

Mr Compton deserves sympathy, he really does. Losing your yacht at sea can ruin your entire day - though impressions are, with his high-powered position in the City, that he will not feel seriously underprivileged. Which means he probably wouldn't feel too put out if the RNLI and the various other rescue teams involved presented him with a sizeable bill.

Silly billies

After all, if you can afford to play silly billies, you can afford to pay. And that's what going to sea with an under-qualified crew is, right? Playing silly billies. And you're playing even bigger silly billies if you decide you are going to be the only competent crew - and there's no such thing as going to the head, coming down with food poisoning of breaking your leg in the forward furling drum.

Gypsy Moth IV

Compare £250,000 with the £300,000 spent on rebuilding the craft in the other significant accident of this week when Gypsy Moth IV ran up on the coral of Rangiroa Atoll, the other side of the world in Tahiti. Working for charity more than a joy ride, Gypsy Moth IV had a fully qualified skipper, a qualified mate and a qualified female deck hand.

Excusable errors

Gypsy Moth IV was in largely uncharted waters. Maybe one of the teenagers aboard distracted the crew at the wrong moment. Maybe there was a wind gust, or an unforeseen current surge. Maybe there was a coral outcrop that had never been captured on Admiralty data.

Whatever the cause, there was certainly no error of judgement like going below as the only competent mariner aboard and leaving the helm in the hands of a novice in waters where known and charted hazards are visibly present.

Be safe, get qualified

Very thankfully the passion we share for going to sea is one o the most rewarding any human can experience. It is also dangerous without taking proper care in the first place. £ 250,000 is a heavy price to pay for making a mistake. But woefully inadequate if there's a life involved.

We all learn by our mistakes and we never stop learning. We know the risks. Now, are you ready to go to sea again yet?



Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Comment on this in our forum:
 You say:
Using this form will also register you with the site.
Forum Topic:
Thread title:
Description: (optional)
Message:
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
E-mail me when a response is made?
Related articles:
Sweden plans boat driving licences
Swedish Government to introduce licences as pleasure boat deaths hit 35-40 a year
Beneteau Oceanis 411
With more than 1,000 sold, it's claimed to be the most popular cruiser ever
Beneteau Group hopes to hit one billion euros
The world's biggest sailing yacht builder expects to go on growing, thanks to new technology, new markets, and bigger boats
Time for those training courses
From navigation to sea survival, the RYA offers courses for every sailor, and this is a good time to enrol
More thoughts on 'driving licences'
The forum thread Are 'driving licences' inevitable? has generated a lot of horror stories and some interesting suggestions
Cathy's Blog: Driving licences
Is the traditional freedom of the sea threatened by untrained learners?
Inside Information DVD
49er World Champions have teamed up with their buddies at Volkswagen to bring you a DVD containing all their ‘Inside Information’ on sailing
The Beneteau 25
A mini-Volvo 60 from the Bruce Farr design board.
The Beneteau First 260
Here is another modern concept built for accommodation and performance...
The Beneteau First 211
The transition from dinghy to cruiser will be made easier for a family
Be Prepared
What if on a long passage the actual weather situation changes fast?

Article Search

Support Our Partners


 Send to friend | Join Now ^ Top of Page
About TheMainSail
- About Us
- Privacy Policy
- Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to THEMAINSAIL RSS news feed.
Contact Us
- Support
- Advertise with us
- FAQ
- Retailers: free site review
Magicalia Digital Publishing
Cycling
- BIKEmagic
- RoadCyclingUK
- SheCycles
- LondonCycleSport
- Visordown
- ProTourNews
Outdoors
- OUTDOORSmagic
- FISHINGmagic
- GOLFmagic
- TheMainSail
Lifestyle
- ThinkBaby
- Gardening.co.uk
- AVReview
- ThinkCamera
Hobbies
- ModelFlying
- MilitaryModelling
- ModelBoats
- GetWoodWorking

- Full Portfolio
© 1999-2008 Magicalia Ltd.